Discovering Salem's Micro Neighborhoods: A Journey Through Pickering Wharf

Exploring the Charm of Salem

Salem is without a doubt one of the most fun cities to visit. Its vast history and bountiful options of things to do and see make it a must-visit destination. The downtown area is a vibrant mix of shops, attractions, and restaurants that stretch across Essex, Central, Washington, and Church Streets. But wait, there’s so much more to Salem than just downtown!

The Hidden Gems of Salem

There are plenty of micro neighborhoods to explore, and you’ll want to visit them all. Our series will help you discover fantastic shops, attractions, and restaurants that you can explore during your visit.

Part two of this series takes us to Pickering Wharf. This area runs from the main intersection in front of Destination Salem (Derby, Washington, and Congress Streets) in the Seaport District all the way down to the iconic House of the Seven Gables. Trust me, it’s worth your time to stroll through this charming area.

A Brief History of Pickering Wharf

Pickering Wharf is named after the Pickering Oil Company, which dates back to around 1838. They operated out of Union Wharf, the previous name for the wharf. The development of Pickering Wharf began when the Pickering Oil Company sold the land at 50% of its assessed value. In return, they received permission to relocate their oil tanks further down Derby Street, near the New England Power Plant.

The Salem Five Cents Saving Bank, along with three partners, purchased the property and invested $15 million to develop it into a mixed-use design. This plan included condominiums, restaurants, retail stores, and a marina on the 5.5-acre waterfront site. Construction started around 1977, and Pickering Wharf officially opened in 1979.

Interestingly, there's a long-standing belief that the Pickering Oil Company descends from John Pickering, who arrived in Salem in the early 1630s. However, an exact connection has never been confirmed. It’s thought that George W. Pickering, the founder of Pickering Oil, was related to John Pickering.

The Pickering House, located at 18 Broad Street, housed ten successive generations of the Pickering family, including Colonel Timothy Pickering, who played a significant role in the American Revolution. The Pickering family has been integral to Salem’s growth over the centuries.

Dining and Shopping at Pickering Wharf

Some of the first restaurants at Pickering Wharf included the Chase House (now known as Longboards) and Victoria Station (now Finz). Other shops included Peter Barter Flowers, Colonial Gifts, Bewitching Yarn, Country Curtains, Crabtree & Evelyn, Pappagallo's Shoes, Putnam Pantry Candies, Regina Pizzeria, and Stoned Elephant Gifts. The aim was to create an 18th-century shopping village.

Today, Pickering Wharf and the surrounding area boast over 40 shops, restaurants, and attractions. It’s a beautiful spot to enjoy views of Salem’s historic harbor and the Salem Maritime National Historic Park.

Must-Visit Shops and Restaurants

Let’s dive into some of the highlights you can’t miss at Pickering Wharf:

100 Derby Country Store

100 Derby Country Store (100 Derby Street) is a charming boutique that offers a delightful array of products. From enchanting candles and witch-themed gifts to carefully crafted handmade treasures and exquisite pottery, this store is a haven for those seeking unique and artisanal items. Whether you're looking for a special gift or simply indulging in some sweet treats, Derby Country Store is sure to captivate with its diverse selection.

Amazing Pizza

Amazing Pizza (62 Wharf Street) is a vibrant artisanal pizzeria where you can order creative pies in a welcoming, high-energy atmosphere. Whether you’re stopping in for a crispy thin-crust pizza, a fresh salad, or a casual meal before exploring the waterfront, the menu offers a perfect mix of classic comfort and gourmet flair. You’ll also find bold, unique flavor profiles, gluten-free crust options, and locally sourced ingredients. Every slice is made to order with passion!

Brodie’s Seaport

Brodie’s Seaport (215 Derby Street) serves the freshest seasonal seafood, outstanding burgers, steak tips, flatbreads, and more. They have a carefully chosen beer and wine list, plus a full bar to elevate your dining experience. It’s a place where great food, great drinks, and great music come together. The wrap-around bar features nine large TVs, perfect for catching your favorite sporting events. In warmer months, the outdoor patio is a superb spot to enjoy your meal.

Bunghole Liquors

Bunghole Liquors (204 Derby Street) is a local liquor store with a colorful history. It used to be a funeral parlor nearly 100 years ago and was a speakeasy during Prohibition. You could gain entrance to the basement with a secret password or a special knock to drink among your deceased friends and neighbors. And don’t worry, "Bung Hole" isn’t dirty; it refers to the hole in the keg where you insert the spigot to pour out the goodness inside.

The Cauldron Black

The Cauldron Black (65 Wharf Street) features several altars dedicated to a diverse range of spirits and forces, lovingly maintained to protect, uplift, and empower their clients and community. Their Divination Room is available for those seeking spiritual consultations and services or the opportunity to participate in meaningful, personalized rituals.

Chambers of Terror

Chambers of Terror (59 Wharf Street) is a premier haunted attraction filled with spine-tingling scares and theatrical storytelling. Whether you’re stopping in for a classic walk-through haunt or a dose of adrenaline-pumping fun, the attraction offers immersive sets and terrifying live actors. You’ll find bold, professionally designed scares that pay homage to horror cinema and local lore alike.

The Chocolate Pantry

The Chocolate Pantry (63 Wharf Street) is an artisanal confectionery offering world-class chocolates and international treats. This shop is an indulgent escape for the senses. Stop in for hand-rolled truffles, a gift box of gourmet pralines, or a sampling of fine European bars. You’ll find bold, sophisticated flavor profiles, including dark chocolate sea salt caramels and traditional Turkish delights.

Circle of Stitches

Circle of Stitches (78 Wharf Street) is a witchy boutique and full-service yarn shop in the heart of the wharf. When you visit, you'll find a selection of gifts and items for the home made by independent artists and companies with values that align with the shop. They have locally made soy candles, local jewelry, independently published tarot decks, crystals, and more.

Coven

Coven (63B Wharf Street) is a "darkly inclined" gothic boutique specializing in alternative fashion, mystical accessories, and witchy gifts. It offers a curated, immersive shopping experience with products like edgy clothing, cosmetics, and curated oddities. Don’t miss the "I put a spell on you..." couch designed for photo opportunities!

Craft Witch

Craft Witch (102 Wharf Street) is a charming artisanal boutique featuring handmade goods, local craftsmanship, hand-poured candles, unique ritual tools, and mystical home décor. The shop offers a curated selection of enchanting finds, including small-batch apothecaries and one-of-a-kind art pieces.

Dave Eng's Flowers

Dave Eng's Flowers (136 ½ Derby Street) is a full-service florist specializing in the beauty of nature and the art of floral design. The shop offers a legacy of expertise and personal service, with bold, fresh blooms ranging from exotic tropicals to classic roses.

The Enchanted Shop

The Enchanted Shop (98 Wharf Street) is a magical shop for Witches and Muggles alike. With warm colors and a friendly atmosphere, it proudly hosts Laurie Cabot, The Official Witch of Salem, and her daughter Penny Cabot. They offer the largest selection of hand-crafted magical items and various classes, workshops, and readings.

The Finery Shop

The Finery Shop (63A Wharf Street) is a boutique specializing in accessories and gifts. Known for its curated selection of fashion-forward and classic items, the shop features sterling silver jewelry, handbags, scarves, hats, and bridal accessories.

Finz

Finz (86 Wharf Street) offers innovative, sustainable menus, raw & sushi bars, and a carefully paired wine list. Their menu emphasizes creatively prepared fresh seasonal seafood, and the raw bar offers the freshest local oysters, clams, chilled lobster, colossal crab, and jumbo shrimp.

Hemlock

Hemlock (96 Wharf Street) is a sophisticated boutique with curated fashion and modern lifestyle goods. Whether you’re stopping in for elevated apparel, unique apothecary finds, or thoughtfully designed home accents, the shop offers a refined selection that blends coastal vibes with an edgy, contemporary aesthetic.

House of Boo

House of Boo (74 Wharf Street) is a spirited boutique that loves all things spooky and the city's year-round Halloween spirit. Whether you’re looking for unique apparel, handcrafted home decor, or a one-of-a-kind souvenir, the shop offers a curated selection of "boo-tiful" finds.

The House of the Seven Gables

The House of the Seven Gables (115 Derby Street) is a 1668 colonial mansion famous for its seven gables. Made famous by Nathaniel Hawthorne's 1851 novel, it was restored in 1910 and opened as a museum and Settlement House to support the local immigrant community. Enjoy public programs, tours of the historic mansion, and relax on the seaside lawn and gardens today.

Jaho Artisan Coffee

Jaho Artisan Coffee (197 Derby Street) is a specialty coffee roaster, coffee shop, and wine bar. It’s a cozy hangout pairing espresso drinks and lots of teas with light bites, baked goods, and desserts. Live slow!

Joe’s Fresh Fish Prints

Joe’s Fresh Fish Prints (82 Wharf Street) is a unique art gallery featuring ancient Japanese art of Gyotaku and New England’s maritime heritage. Stop in to browse original hand-pressed art or watch a live demonstration of the printing process.

King Lewis Engraving & Gifts

King Lewis Engraving & Gifts (124 Derby Street) is a specialized custom workshop dedicated to the art of personalization and precision craftsmanship. You can get a custom-etched glass, a personalized leather gift, or a unique souvenir to commemorate your visit to the Witch City.

Longboards

Longboards (76 Wharf Street) is the neighborhood joint for locals and a must-stop for visitors. It’s a lively, casual space perfect for everyone. They stay true to their New England roots with award-winning lobster rolls and unique flatbread pizzas served on actual long boards.

Mainstay Social

Mainstay Social (225 Derby Street) is a vibrant waterfront destination and stylish gathering place. Whether you’re stopping in for a refreshing craft cocktail on the harbor-view patio or a lively weekend brunch, the menu offers a modern take on seaside dining.

Maitland Farms

Maitland Farms (84 Derby Street) is a farm-to-table destination where food enthusiasts discover the highest quality artisanal products and seasonal harvests. Whether you are stopping in for hand-crafted fermented goods or fresh local dairy, the shop offers a direct connection to the region's agricultural heritage.

Mercy Tavern

Mercy Tavern (148 Derby Street) is named after a belief in Mercy as a beautiful, powerful, and revolutionary concept. The tavern is committed to delicious, locally sourced food and drink, emphasizing fun, friendship, and community.

The Ossuary

The Ossuary (77 Wharf Street) is a gothic boutique offering curated dark fashion and handmade apparel. It features high-end gothic couture and unique gifts in a designed, catacomb-inspired setting.

Partridge in a Bear Tree

Partridge in a Bear Tree (82 Wharf Street) is a festive gift shop specializing in year-round Christmas decorations and unique ornaments. Established in 2002, it’s known for high-quality seasonal items.

Popped!

Popped! (84 Wharf Street) is a gourmet confectionery where families and foodies connect over small-batch treats. Whether you’re stopping in for hand-crafted popcorn or a scoop of premium ice cream, the shop offers artisanal quality and local charm.

Salem Arts Association

Salem Arts Association (88 Wharf Street) is a vibrant community art center featuring local talent. You can browse new exhibitions, attend artist workshops, or find unique handcrafted jewelry.

Salem Ink Tattoo & Art Gallery

Salem Ink Tattoo & Art Gallery (201 Derby Street) is a custom tattoo and piercing studio featuring high-quality body jewelry. The studio offers a clean, welcoming environment with bold, versatile styles.

Salem Maritime National Historic Park

Salem Maritime National Historic Park (160 Derby Street) was established in 1938 as the first National Historic Site in the U.S. It consists of nine acres of land and 12 historic structures along the waterfront, preserving New England's maritime history.

Salem Waterfront Hotel & Suites

Salem Waterfront Hotel & Suites (225 Derby Street) is conveniently located in the heart of downtown Salem. Nestled right on the historic Pickering Wharf, it’s within walking distance of Salem’s most popular attractions.

Sea Level

Sea Level (94 Wharf Street) boasts two floors with spectacular views of Salem Harbor. They feature fresh seafood, a raw bar, pizzas, sandwiches, and craft beers. Their menu emphasizes creatively prepared local seafood.

Timeless Life Treasures

Timeless Life Treasures (68 Wharf Street) can create a piece that you will cherish for a lifetime. They offer a variety of handmade giftware and services, including engraving and jewelry repairs.

Tomo’s Tackle

Tomo’s Tackle (104 Wharf Street) is a saltwater fishing shop with local fishing reports and expert angling advice. The shop offers specialized gear for every skill level.

The Trade House

The Trade House (156 Derby Street) is a pub near the seaport. It’s a gathering place where friends and families connect over great meals and even better conversation.

Waite & Pierce

Waite & Pierce (193 Derby Street) pays homage to the original Friendship, which conducted business for almost 50 years. Explore their exclusive line of apparel, jewelry, home goods, and gifts.

The Wicked Wardrobe

The Wicked Wardrobe (201 Derby Street) is a couple-owned dark fashion and cult brand consignment shop. They specialize in gothic and cult brands and vintage clothing for all sizes and genders.

The Witchery

The Witchery (86 Wharf Street) is a woman-owned, queer-friendly creative space. It has grown into a broom-making, bookbinding, and spell jar workshop space.

Witch Way Gifts

Witch Way Gifts (155 Derby Street) offers a vast selection of gifts, including books, housewares, and spell kits. There’s something for everyone, from Wicca to pagan practices.

Witch Pix

Witch Pix (29 Congress Street) is an immersive costume photography. Guests of all ages and genders are styled into handcrafted costumes and are guided by professional photographers through magical, story-inspired photo sets. Since 2003, Witch Pix has been creating unforgettable portraits that blend imagination, play, and a little bit of Salem’s famous magic.

Wolf Next Door

Wolf Next Door (142 Derby Street) is a charming artisanal bakery and coffee house. You’ll find bold, creative specials made with fresh, local ingredients.

Ye Old Pepper Candy Shop

Ye Old Pepper Candy Shop (122 Derby Street) started in 1806 and is America’s oldest candy company. They sell all sorts of chocolates and confections, continuing a long-standing tradition.

Conclusion: Embrace the Magic of Salem

Pickering Wharf is just one of the many enchanting spots in Salem. With its rich history, diverse shops, and delicious eateries, it’s a place where every visitor can find something special. So, when you plan your trip to Salem, make sure to explore this hidden gem. You won’t regret it!